party.net › Never Have I Ever › Halloween

Halloween Never Have I Ever questions

Halloween prompts about costumes, candy and being more scared than you let on.

Halloween party games

More Never Have I Ever lists

By group

By holiday

How to play Never Have I Ever

1. Everyone holds up ten fingers.
2. Read a card: "Never have I ever..."
3. If you've done it, put a finger down and, if the group insists, tell the story. The last one with fingers up wins.

Updated November 2026.

1. Never have I ever eaten candy for breakfast on November 1.
2. Never have I ever been scared by a Halloween decoration in a store.
3. Never have I ever worn the same costume two years in a row.
4. Never have I ever gotten pumpkin guts in my hair.
5. Never have I ever traded candy with a brother, sister or friend.
6. Never have I ever dressed up as an animal.
7. Never have I ever told a ghost story with a flashlight under my chin.
8. Never have I ever been too scared to walk up to a decorated house.
9. Never have I ever made a costume out of a cardboard box.
10. Never have I ever hidden my candy from my family.
11. Never have I ever been given a toothbrush while trick-or-treating.
12. Never have I ever bobbed for apples.
13. Never have I ever screamed at something that turned out to be a coat on a chair.
14. Never have I ever been on a hayride.
15. Never have I ever worn a costume that nobody could guess.
16. Never have I ever jumped out and scared someone in my family.
17. Never have I ever gotten lost in a corn maze.
18. Never have I ever eaten so much candy my stomach hurt.
19. Never have I ever dropped a pumpkin.
20. Never have I ever had to wear a winter coat over my costume.
21. Never have I ever dressed up a pet for Halloween.
22. Never have I ever taken more than one piece from a "take one" bowl.
23. Never have I ever watched a scary movie from behind a pillow.
24. Never have I ever left a haunted house through the emergency exit.
25. Never have I ever gone to a Halloween party in my regular clothes.
26. Never have I ever bought a costume the day before Halloween.
27. Never have I ever eaten my kid's candy after bedtime.
28. Never have I ever turned off the lights and pretended not to be home.
29. Never have I ever gone to work in a costume when nobody else did.
30. Never have I ever left a carved pumpkin on the porch until it collapsed.
31. Never have I ever checked the back seat of my car after a scary movie.
32. Never have I ever worn a couples costume.
33. Never have I ever regretted a costume by 9 pm.
34. Never have I ever handed out the candy I don't like so I would not eat it.
35. Never have I ever screamed louder than the kids in a haunted house.
36. Never have I ever lost part of my costume at a party.
37. Never have I ever spent a whole party explaining my costume.
38. Never have I ever been to a costume party at work.
39. Never have I ever gone trick-or-treating when I was clearly too old.
40. Never have I ever been on a ghost tour.
41. Never have I ever fallen asleep in face paint and ruined a pillowcase.
42. Never have I ever slept with a light on after a scary movie.
43. Never have I ever sent my partner to check on a strange noise.
44. Never have I ever had a drink ladled out of a cauldron.
45. Never have I ever kept Halloween decorations up past Thanksgiving.
46. Never have I ever bought half-price candy on November 1.

Tips for a better game

• Use five fingers for a shorter round.
• Anyone who puts a finger down alone owes the group the full story.
• Take turns reading so everyone gets to choose a card.

Questions people ask

What are some good Halloween Never Have I Ever questions?

Five from this list: Never have I ever gotten pumpkin guts in my hair. Never have I ever screamed at something that turned out to be a coat on a chair. Never have I ever taken more than one piece from a "take one" bowl. Never have I ever checked the back seat of my car after a scary movie. Never have I ever fallen asleep in face paint and ruined a pillowcase.

More party games