What are some good Halloween Most Likely To questions?

Five from this list: Who's most likely to trade away the good candy by mistake? Who's most likely to turn into a werewolf and still finish their homework? Who's most likely to be the first to say "let's split up"? Who's most likely to sleep with the lights on after a scary movie? Who's most likely to decide the apartment is haunted because of one creaky pipe?

party.net › Most Likely To › Halloween

Halloween Most Likely To questions

Halloween questions: who screams first in a haunted house, who eats all the candy, who wears the best costume.

Who's most likely to

eat all their Halloween candy in one night

Halloween party games

More Most Likely To lists

All Most Likely To questions438 in one deck

By group

Most Likely To questions for kids152 questions Most Likely To questions for teens187 questions Most Likely To questions for adults203 questions Most Likely To questions for couples76 questions Most Likely To questions for families190 questions Most Likely To questions for work119 questions

By holiday

Thanksgiving Most Likely To questions46 questions Christmas Most Likely To questions53 questions New Year's Eve Most Likely To questions46 questions

How to play Most Likely To

Sit in a circle so everyone can see each other.
One person reads the card: "Who's most likely to..."
On three, everyone points. The person with the most votes tells a story that proves or disproves it.

All 46 Halloween Most Likely To questions

Updated November 2026.

Who's most likely to eat all their Halloween candy in one night?
Who's most likely to scream at a plastic spider?
Who's most likely to wear their costume to bed?
Who's most likely to trade away the good candy by mistake?
Who's most likely to make friends with a ghost?
Who's most likely to get lost in a corn maze?
Who's most likely to carve the goofiest pumpkin?
Who's most likely to hide behind the couch during a spooky movie?
Who's most likely to scare the person who was trying to scare them?
Who's most likely to keep saying "boo" until someone finally jumps?
Who's most likely to still have Halloween candy left in the spring?
Who's most likely to start planning next year's costume on November 1?
Who's most likely to turn into a werewolf and still finish their homework?
Who's most likely to try to adopt every black cat they see?
Who's most likely to knock on the same door twice for more candy?
Who's most likely to trip over their own costume?
Who's most likely to jump at their own shadow in a haunted house?
Who's most likely to sort their candy by color before eating any?
Who's most likely to tell a ghost story that turns out to be about a sandwich?
Who's most likely to beg to trick-or-treat for one more block?
Who's most likely to survive a horror movie by staying home?
Who's most likely to be the first to say "let's split up"?
Who's most likely to go check on the noise in the basement?
Who's most likely to start making their costume the afternoon of the party?
Who's most likely to win the costume contest without trying?
Who's most likely to open the trick-or-treat candy a week early?
Who's most likely to show up in regular clothes and say they came as themselves?
Who's most likely to laugh all the way through a haunted house?
Who's most likely to apologize to a haunted house actor for screaming at them?
Who's most likely to leave their decorations up until spring?
Who's most likely to sleep with the lights on after a scary movie?
Who's most likely to spend more on their dog's costume than their own?
Who's most likely to turn the porch light off at 8 pm and pretend nobody is home?
Who's most likely to bring a spooky dish to the office that nobody dares to try?
Who's most likely to wear a costume on a video call and never mention it?
Who's most likely to point out the plot holes during a scary movie?
Who's most likely to wear a pun costume that takes five minutes to explain?
Who's most likely to charge their kid a candy tax?
Who's most likely to talk their partner into a couples costume?
Who's most likely to grab their partner's arm at every jump scare?
Who's most likely to decide the apartment is haunted because of one creaky pipe?
Who's most likely to buy a giant skeleton and have nowhere to store it?
Who's most likely to be mistaken for a decoration at their own party?
Who's most likely to keep the office candy bowl full all month?
Who's most likely to stay in character all night?
Who's most likely to fall asleep before the scary part?

Tips for a better game

Pointing at yourself is allowed only if you tell the story that earns it.
Settle a tie with a quick re-vote between the two people.
For couples, both answer "me or you" at the same time and see whether you agree.

Questions people ask

What are some good Halloween Most Likely To questions?: Five from this list: Who's most likely to trade away the good candy by mistake? Who's most likely to turn into a werewolf and still finish their homework? Who's most likely to be the first to say "let's split up"? Who's most likely to sleep with the lights on after a scary movie? Who's most likely to decide the apartment is haunted because of one creaky pipe?